ANTALYA, Turkey – The closing plenary of COP31 has stalled, with European and small island delegations openly rejecting the latest draft text as a step backward. Negotiators are now facing a binary choice: accept a weak compromise or watch the summit collapse into a fragmented political declaration.
“The text as it is was presented to us – Germany will not be able to agree,” said German Climate Minister Carsten Schneider, signaling a hard line against the current proposal. This stance is shared by France and the EU, with officials warning of a “very real possibility” that COP31 ends without a deal.
Small States Demand More Than Process
For the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) and Least Developed Countries, the draft is not just insufficient; it is dangerous. Darragh O’Brien, Ireland’s Climate and Energy Minister, said the talks are diminishing “by the hour” and lack the climate ambition needed.
“This latest text is a total mess and countries should throw it out. It fails to deliver vital climate finance to the vulnerable while promoting far-fetched and eye wateringly expensive carbon removal technologies which is a gift to the fossil fuel industry,” said Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa.
The criticism is sharp. Adow noted that the text “recognises” the crisis 40 times but only “decides” on action 5 times, and those decisions are peripheral. Without a specific figure for the $120 billion fund, the package is seen as a delay tactic.
Presidency Urges Unity Amidst Tension
COP president Murat Kurum has urged delegates to find consensus, stating that “no one got everything they wanted but everyone can find something of themselves in this text.” However, the mood in the plenary room is tense, with Australian Minister Chris Bowen appearing despondent during late-night huddles.
Panama has vowed to formally object if the final agreement does not cap oil production or acknowledge the failure to limit warming. “The talks are being held hostage by a petroleum mafia,” said Panamanian Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro, calling for immediate reform.
What to watch next is whether the EU and AOSIS will move to formally block the text or sign a political declaration. If the latter, the burden of solving the finance and fossil fuel deadlock shifts to the next COP, likely in 2027, a timeline many argue is too late for the climate crisis.