WASHINGTON – The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday dealt the Trump administration a major defeat, declining to hear an appeal aimed at canceling millions of dollars in federal university research grants. The justices left intact a lower court ruling that blocked executive agencies from freezing funds targeted under administration directives against diversity initiatives.
With no noted dissents, the high court’s refusal to intervene preserves a preliminary injunction issued by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. That ruling requires the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities to maintain $59 million in active funding for University of California faculty and researchers.
Lower Court Found Free Speech Violations in Grant Freezes
The underlying dispute arose after the administration ordered federal agencies to terminate grants connected to diversity, equity, and inclusion, as well as gender studies and environmental justice. University researchers sued, arguing that the cancellations violated constitutional free speech protections by punishing scholars for specific viewpoints.
A three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit agreed, ruling that the government cannot selectively defund scientific and humanities projects simply because agency officials disagree with their thematic language. The appeals court noted that keyword searches had ensnared projects studying fundamental biological systems, including legume rhizobia mutualism and basic leaf variations.
“It means that the 9th Circuit ruling stands and all of the grants that were cut off based on the perceived viewpoint of the research must continue to be restored,” said Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of Berkeley Law and lead counsel for the researchers.
The Justice Department defended the executive branch authority to direct taxpayer funds toward favored government perspectives. Solicitor General D. John Sauer warned the justices that restricting executive discretion over grant administration would impair the operational flexibility of every future presidential administration.
Broader Fallout From White House Spending Reviews
The contested grant cancellations followed broader federal spending reviews spearheaded last year by the Department of Government Efficiency. That oversight effort targeted billions of dollars across federal agencies, relying heavily on automated keyword screenings to identify and eliminate contested awards.
Legal scholars say the Supreme Court’s decision not to take up the case leaves open broader questions regarding executive spending authority. However, Monday’s action ensures that academic grantees currently locked in litigation retain vital financial support while lower courts consider the merits of the permanent injunction.
Federal district courts will now proceed with permanent hearings on the constitutional limits of executive grant terminations. Researchers and university coalitions nationwide plan to cite the 9th Circuit precedent in parallel challenges pending in other federal jurisdictions.